luckberg/unraid-docker-manager
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

chore: complete v1.2 milestone — archive and tag

Browse Source 
Archive v1.2 Modularization & Polish milestone:
- Archive ROADMAP.md, REQUIREMENTS.md, and audit to milestones/
- Evolve PROJECT.md with v1.2 validated requirements and decisions
- Reorganize ROADMAP.md with collapsed milestone groupings
- Delete REQUIREMENTS.md (fresh for next milestone)
- Update STATE.md and MILESTONES.md

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Lucas Berger
2026-02-08 18:50:03 -05:00
parent 4b82044031
commit e7eadd088c
7 changed files with 458 additions and 203 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files
.planning/milestones/v1.2-MILESTONE-AUDIT.md
+146
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,146 @@
---
milestone: v1.2
audited: 2026-02-08
status: tech_debt
scores:
requirements: 12/12
phases: 6/6
integration: 7/7
flows: 6/6
gaps:
requirements: []
integration: []
flows: []
tech_debt:
- phase: 10.2-better-logging-and-log-management
items:
- "Descoped: ring buffer, debug commands, trace logging (n8n static data platform limitation)"
- "Only correlation IDs + structured errors retained from original plan"
- phase: 10-workflow-modularization
items:
- "3 orphan nodes remain: Build Action Command, Build Immediate Action Command, Prepare Cancel Return (legacy dead code, unreachable)"
- phase: 12-polish-audit
items:
- "Missing VERIFICATION.md (phase has SUMMARY.md files, all requirements closed, but no formal verification report)"
- phase: 11-update-all-callback-limits
items:
- "Old batch parsers retained for graceful migration (batch:toggle:, batch:nav:, batch:exec: formats)"
---
# Milestone v1.2 Audit Report: Modularization & Polish
**Audited:** 2026-02-08
**Status:** tech_debt (all requirements met, no critical blockers, accumulated non-critical debt)
## Requirements Coverage
| Requirement | Description | Phase | Status |
|-------------|-------------|-------|--------|
| MOD-01 | Main workflow broken into logical sub-workflows | 10/10.1 | ✓ SATISFIED |
| MOD-02 | Sub-workflows callable without duplication | 10/10.1 | ✓ SATISFIED |
| BATCH-04 | Update all via text command | 11/12 | ✓ SATISFIED |
| BATCH-05 | Update all via inline keyboard | 11/12 | ✓ SATISFIED |
| BATCH-06 | Batch selection 5+ containers | 11 | ✓ SATISFIED |
| BATCH-07 | Long container names in batch | 11 | ✓ SATISFIED |
| UNR-01 | Unraid update badge | 12 | ✓ SATISFIED (documented limitation) |
| ENV-01 | TELEGRAM_USERID documentation | 12 | ✓ SATISFIED |
| ENV-02 | TELEGRAM_BOT_TOKEN documentation | 12 | ✓ SATISFIED |
| DEBT-01 | README documents proxy architecture | 12 | ✓ SATISFIED |
| DEBT-02 | Fix duplicate --max-time flags | 12 | ✓ SATISFIED (verified fixed) |
| DEBT-03 | Consolidate duplicate update flow | 10 | ✓ SATISFIED |
**Score: 12/12 requirements satisfied**
## Phase Verification
| Phase | Name | Plans | Verification | Status |
|-------|------|-------|-------------|--------|
| 10 | Workflow Modularization | 7/7 | 10-VERIFICATION.md (passed, 6/6) | ✓ Complete |
| 10.1 | Aggressive Modularization | 9/9 | 10.1-VERIFICATION.md (passed, 16/16) | ✓ Complete |
| 10.2 | Better Logging & Log Management | 4/4 | 10.2-VERIFICATION.md (passed, 4/4, descoped) | ✓ Complete |
| 11 | Update All & Callback Limits | 2/2 | 11-VERIFICATION.md (human_needed 7/9, completed in 12-02) | ✓ Complete |
| 12 | Polish & Audit | 2/2 | No VERIFICATION.md (all requirements closed via SUMMARY.md) | ✓ Complete |
| 13 | Documentation Overhaul | 1/1 | 13-VERIFICATION.md (passed, 7/7) | ✓ Complete |
**Score: 6/6 phases complete (25/25 plans executed)**
## Cross-Phase Integration
| Connection | From | To | Status |
|------------|------|-----|--------|
| Sub-workflow wiring | Phase 10/10.1 | All phases | ✓ 17 Execute Workflow nodes properly connected |
| Correlation IDs | Phase 10.2 | All sub-workflows | ✓ 19 Prepare Input nodes pass correlationId |
| Bitmap encoding | Phase 11 | Batch UI sub-workflow | ✓ Base36 BigInt encoding integrated |
| Update All button | Phase 11 | Status sub-workflow | ✓ uall:start callback wired |
| UAT completion | Phase 11 → 12 | BATCH-04/BATCH-05 | ✓ Deferred UAT completed, 9 bugs fixed |
| Documentation chain | Phase 12 → 13 | README/DEPLOY-SUBWORKFLOWS | ✓ Architecture, config, troubleshooting sections |
| Sub-workflow cross-call | Confirmation | Actions | ✓ Confirmed stop actions execute via n8n-actions.json |
**Score: 7/7 integrations verified**
## E2E User Flows
| Flow | Path | Status |
|------|------|--------|
| Text status | User → auth → correlation ID → Keyword Router → Status sub-workflow → Telegram | ✓ Complete |
| Callback routing | User → auth → correlation ID → Parse Callback → Route → sub-workflow → Telegram | ✓ Complete |
| Update All (text) | "update all" → Get Containers → Filter Infra → Confirmation → Batch Loop → Summary | ✓ Complete |
| Update All (keyboard) | uall:start → Answer → Get Containers → Confirmation → Batch Loop → Summary | ✓ Complete |
| Batch selection | Batch mode → Batch UI (bitmap) → Toggle → Execute → batch loop → Summary | ✓ Complete |
| Logs command | "logs X" → Matching sub-workflow → Logs sub-workflow → Send Logs Response | ✓ Complete |
**Score: 6/6 flows verified**
## Tech Debt
### Phase 10.2: Descoped Features
- **Ring buffer, debug commands, trace logging** — removed due to n8n static data platform limitation (execution-scoped, not workflow-scoped)
- Only correlation IDs + structured error returns retained
- Impact: Manual debugging via n8n UI only (no Telegram debug commands)
### Phase 10: Orphan Nodes (3)
- **Build Action Command, Build Immediate Action Command, Prepare Cancel Return** — legacy dead code, unreachable from any user interaction
- Pre-modularization inline action execution paths
- Impact: None (dead code, 3 nodes in 166-node workflow)
### Phase 12: Missing VERIFICATION.md
- Phase completed successfully (12-01, 12-02 SUMMARY.md files exist, all requirements closed)
- No formal verification report was generated
- Impact: Minor documentation gap, no functional impact
### Phase 11: Legacy Batch Parsers
- Old `batch:toggle:`, `batch:nav:`, `batch:exec:` parsers retained alongside new bitmap `b:`, `bn:`, `be:` parsers
- Intended for graceful migration of in-flight messages (30-second window)
- Impact: Minor code bloat, no functional impact
**Total: 4 tech debt items across 4 phases (none blocking)**
## Architecture Summary
```
Telegram Bot → Main Workflow (166 nodes)
├── n8n-update.json (34 nodes) — Container Update
├── n8n-actions.json (11 nodes) — Start/Stop/Restart
├── n8n-logs.json (9 nodes) — Container Logs
├── n8n-batch-ui.json (17 nodes) — Batch Selection UI
├── n8n-status.json (11 nodes) — Container Status/List
├── n8n-confirmation.json (16 nodes) — Confirmation Dialogs
└── n8n-matching.json (23 nodes) — Container Matching
↓
docker-socket-proxy
↓
Docker Engine
```
**Total system nodes:** 287 (166 main + 121 sub-workflows)
**Documentation:** README.md (264 lines), DEPLOY-SUBWORKFLOWS.md (725 lines)
## Conclusion
Milestone v1.2 has met all 12 requirements with no critical gaps. Cross-phase integration is solid across all 7 sub-workflows. All 6 E2E user flows verified. The 4 tech debt items are non-blocking and can be tracked in backlog.
**Recommendation:** Proceed to milestone completion (`/gsd:complete-milestone`).
---
*Audited: 2026-02-08*
*Auditor: Claude (milestone audit workflow)*
.planning/milestones/v1.2-REQUIREMENTS.md
+127
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,127 @@
# Requirements Archive: v1.2 Modularization & Polish
**Archived:** 2026-02-08
**Status:** SHIPPED
For current requirements, see `.planning/REQUIREMENTS.md`.
---
# Requirements: Unraid Docker Manager
**Defined:** 2026-02-04
**Core Value:** When you get a container update notification or notice a service is down, you can immediately investigate and act from your phone.
## v1.0 Requirements (Validated)
### Core Commands
- ✓ **CMD-01**: User can send a message to the bot and receive a response — v1.0
- ✓ **CMD-02**: User can check container status via "status" command — v1.0
- ✓ **CMD-03**: User can start a container by name — v1.0
- ✓ **CMD-04**: User can stop a container by name — v1.0
- ✓ **CMD-05**: User can restart a container by name — v1.0
- ✓ **CMD-06**: User can update a container (pull new image, recreate) — v1.0
- ✓ **CMD-07**: User can view container logs with configurable line count — v1.0
### Security
- ✓ **SEC-01**: Bot only responds to configured Telegram user ID — v1.0
## v1.1 Requirements (Validated)
### n8n API
- ✓ **API-01**: n8n API access for programmatic workflow management — v1.1
### Docker Security
- ✓ **SEC-02**: Docker socket access via filtered proxy (no direct socket mount) — v1.1
### Inline Keyboard UX
- ✓ **UX-01**: Container list with pagination via inline keyboard — v1.1
- ✓ **UX-02**: Action buttons for container operations — v1.1
- ✓ **UX-03**: Confirmation dialogs for dangerous actions (stop, update) — v1.1
- ✓ **UX-04**: Progress feedback via message edits during operations — v1.1
### Batch Operations
- ✓ **BATCH-01**: Batch start multiple containers at once — v1.1
- ✓ **BATCH-02**: Batch stop multiple containers at once — v1.1
- ✓ **BATCH-03**: Batch restart multiple containers at once — v1.1
## v1.2 Requirements (Active)
### Modularization
- ✓ **MOD-01**: Main workflow broken into logical sub-workflows for maintainability — Phase 10/10.1
- ✓ **MOD-02**: Sub-workflows callable from main workflow without duplication — Phase 10/10.1
### Batch Updates
- ✓ **BATCH-04**: User can update all containers with :latest tag via text command ("update all") — Phase 11/12
- ✓ **BATCH-05**: User can update all containers with :latest tag via inline keyboard — Phase 11/12
- ✓ **BATCH-06**: Batch selection keyboard supports selecting more than 2 containers — Phase 11
- ✓ **BATCH-07**: Batch selection keyboard supports containers with long names — Phase 11
### Unraid Integration
- ✓ **UNR-01**: After bot updates a container, Unraid UI no longer shows "update available" for that container — Documented as known limitation with workaround, Phase 12
### Environment & Config
- ✓ **ENV-01**: Documentation clarifies TELEGRAM_USERID env var necessity (required vs hardcoded) — Phase 12
- ✓ **ENV-02**: Documentation clarifies TELEGRAM_BOT_TOKEN env var necessity (env var vs n8n credential) — Phase 12
### Technical Debt
- ✓ **DEBT-01**: README documents proxy architecture (not direct docker.sock mounting) — Phase 12
- ✓ **DEBT-02**: Fix duplicate --max-time flags in image pull command — Verified fixed (single --max-time 600, no duplicates), Phase 12
- ✓ **DEBT-03**: Consolidate duplicated update flow between single and batch paths — Phase 10
## v2+ Requirements (Deferred)
### Resource Monitoring
- **RES-01**: User can query resource usage ("what's using the most memory?")
### Notifications
- **NOTF-01**: Bot proactively notifies when containers have updates available
## Out of Scope
| Feature | Reason |
|---------|--------|
| Take over Unraid notifications | Keep existing notification system, bot is for control |
| Deploy new containers | Manage existing only, not create new ones |
| Natural language understanding | Simple keyword matching sufficient, Claude API adds complexity |
| Proactive monitoring | Bot is reactive (you ask, it answers) |
| Mobile app | Telegram is the interface |
## Traceability
| Requirement | Phase | Status |
|-------------|-------|--------|
| MOD-01 | Phase 10/10.1 | Complete |
| MOD-02 | Phase 10/10.1 | Complete |
| DEBT-03 | Phase 10 | Complete |
| BATCH-04 | Phase 11/12 | Complete |
| BATCH-05 | Phase 11/12 | Complete |
| BATCH-06 | Phase 11 | Complete |
| BATCH-07 | Phase 11 | Complete |
| UNR-01 | Phase 12 | Complete |
| ENV-01 | Phase 12 | Complete |
| ENV-02 | Phase 12 | Complete |
| DEBT-02 | Phase 12 | Complete |
| DEBT-01 | Phase 12 | Complete |
**Coverage:**
- v1.2 requirements: 12 total
- Mapped to phases: 12
- Unmapped: 0 ✓
---
*Requirements defined: 2026-02-04*
*Last updated: 2026-02-04 after v1.2 milestone initialization*
.planning/milestones/v1.2-ROADMAP.md
+188
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,188 @@
# Roadmap — Unraid Docker Manager
## Milestones
- **v1.0 Docker Control via Telegram** — Phases 1-5 (shipped 2026-02-02) -> [Archive](milestones/v1.0-ROADMAP.md)
- **v1.1 n8n Integration & Polish** — Phases 6-9 (shipped 2026-02-04) -> [Archive](milestones/v1.1-ROADMAP.md)
- **v1.2 Modularization & Polish** — Phases 10-13 + 10.1, 10.2 (planned)
---
## v1.2: Modularization & Polish
Modularize the workflow for maintainability, add "update all" functionality, fix callback data limits, and polish remaining issues.
### Phase 10: Workflow Modularization
**Goal:** Break main workflow into modular sub-workflows for maintainability
**Dependencies:** None
**Requirements:** MOD-01, MOD-02, DEBT-03
**Plans:** 7 plans
Plans:
- [x] 10-01-PLAN.md — Orphan node cleanup (removed 2 orphan nodes)
- [x] 10-02-PLAN.md — Extract container update sub-workflow (consolidates DEBT-03)
- [x] 10-03-PLAN.md — Extract container actions sub-workflow (start/stop/restart)
- [x] 10-04-PLAN.md — Integration verification and user checkpoint
- [x] 10-05-PLAN.md — Complete modularization (batch operations, logs sub-workflow)
- [x] 10-06-PLAN.md — Remediation: fix routing gaps, wire logs, cleanup Python scripts
- [x] 10-07-PLAN.md — UAT gap closure: race conditions, data chains, fuzzy matching, error handling
**Success Criteria:**
1. ✓ Workflow split into logical sub-workflows (update, actions, logs)
2. ✓ Sub-workflows callable from main without code duplication
3. ✓ Update flow consolidated between single and batch paths
4. ✓ Actions flow consolidated between single and batch paths
5. ✓ Main workflow reduced from 209 to 192 nodes (-8%)
6. ✓ All existing functionality still works after modularization
**Note:** Deeper modularization (target 120-140 nodes) deferred to Phase 10.1
---
### Phase 10.1: Aggressive Workflow Modularization (INSERTED)
**Goal:** Decompose main workflow to minimal trigger/auth/routing (~50-80 nodes) with domain sub-workflows
**Dependencies:** Phase 10 (initial modularization complete)
**Requirements:** MOD-03 (new)
**Plans:** 9 plans
Plans:
- [x] 10.1-01-PLAN.md — Rename sub-workflows, analyze domain boundaries, get user approval
- [x] 10.1-02-PLAN.md — Extract Batch UI sub-workflow (~50 nodes)
- [x] 10.1-03-PLAN.md — Extract Container Status sub-workflow (~10-15 nodes)
- [x] 10.1-04-PLAN.md — Extract Confirmation sub-workflow (~15-20 nodes)
- [x] 10.1-05-PLAN.md — Integration verification and UAT
- [x] 10.1-06-PLAN.md — Gap closure: Extract Matching/Disambiguation sub-workflow
- [x] 10.1-07-PLAN.md — Gap closure: Code node classification + contract documentation
- [x] 10.1-08-PLAN.md — UAT gap closure: Fix action result statusCode handling (n8n-actions.json)
- [x] 10.1-09-PLAN.md — UAT gap closure: Fix batch keyboard, cancel routing, /list command (n8n-workflow.json)
**Success Criteria:**
1. Main workflow contains only: trigger, auth, keyword routing, sub-workflow dispatch
2. UX/Keyboard sub-workflow handles all batch selection UI and pagination
3. Container Status sub-workflow handles list and status display
4. Confirmation sub-workflow handles all confirmation dialogs
5. Main workflow reduced to ~50-80 nodes (from 192)
6. All sub-workflows have clean input/output contracts
---
### Phase 10.2: Better Logging and Log Management (INSERTED)
**Goal:** Add correlation ID tracking for request tracing across sub-workflow boundaries
**Dependencies:** Phase 10.1 (aggressive modularization complete)
**Requirements:** LOG-01 (error ring buffer), LOG-02 (sub-workflow error propagation), LOG-03 (debug commands), LOG-04 (debug mode tracing)
**Plans:** 4 plans
Plans:
- [x] 10.2-01-PLAN.md -- Error ring buffer foundation + hidden Telegram debug commands
- [x] 10.2-02-PLAN.md -- Sub-workflow error propagation + correlation ID tracking
- [x] 10.2-03-PLAN.md -- Debug mode tracing + deployment verification
- [x] 10.2-04-PLAN.md -- UAT gap closure: wire correlation ID generators and remove orphan nodes
**Success Criteria:** (descoped — n8n static data does not persist between executions)
1. ~~Errors from sub-workflow failures automatically captured in ring buffer~~ (removed — platform limitation)
2. ~~/errors, /clear-errors, /debug, /trace hidden commands~~ (removed — platform limitation)
3. ✓ Correlation IDs trace single user requests across main + sub-workflow boundaries
4. ~~Debug mode captures sub-workflow I/O boundary data~~ (removed — platform limitation)
5. ✓ No regression to existing bot functionality after deployment
6. ✓ All 7 sub-workflows return structured error objects (success/false + error details)
**Note:** n8n workflow static data is execution-scoped, not workflow-scoped. Ring buffer architecture not viable. Retained: correlation IDs, structured error returns, correlationId pass-through.
---
### Phase 11: Update All & Callback Limits
**Goal:** Add "update all" functionality and fix callback data limits for batch selection
**Dependencies:** Phase 10 (modularization provides cleaner base for new features)
**Requirements:** BATCH-04, BATCH-05, BATCH-06, BATCH-07
**Plans:** 2 plans
Plans:
- [x] 11-01-PLAN.md — Bitmap-encoded batch selection (replaces CSV-in-callback to eliminate 64-byte limit)
- [x] 11-02-PLAN.md — Update All inline keyboard button, deployment, and UAT verification
**Success Criteria:**
1. ✓ User can type "update all" to update all :latest containers with confirmation
2. ✓ User can tap "Update All" in inline keyboard to update all :latest containers
3. ✓ Batch selection keyboard allows selecting 5+ containers without hitting callback limit
4. ✓ Containers with long names (20+ chars) can be selected in batch keyboard
---
### Phase 12: Polish & Audit
**Goal:** Clear Unraid update badges, verify environment configuration, and fix remaining tech debt
**Dependencies:** Phase 11 (features complete before polish)
**Requirements:** UNR-01, ENV-01, ENV-02, DEBT-02
**Plans:** 2 plans
Plans:
- [x] 12-01-PLAN.md — Documentation update (README, env vars, DEBT-02 verification) + Unraid badge investigation
- [x] 12-02-PLAN.md — Deferred UAT: Update All text command (BATCH-04) and inline keyboard (BATCH-05)
**Success Criteria:**
1. ✓ Unraid update badge behavior documented as known limitation with workaround (bot bypasses Unraid template system)
2. ✓ Documentation clarifies whether TELEGRAM_USERID env var is required or can be hardcoded
3. ✓ Documentation clarifies whether TELEGRAM_BOT_TOKEN env var is required or if n8n credential suffices
4. ✓ Image pull command has single --max-time flag (600s)
---
### Phase 13: Documentation Overhaul
**Goal:** Update README and documentation to reflect current architecture and features
**Dependencies:** Phase 12 (core features complete before documentation)
**Requirements:** DEBT-01
**Plans:** 1 plan
Plans:
- [x] 13-01-PLAN.md — README overhaul (architecture, configuration, troubleshooting, v1.2 features) + remove outdated DEPLOYMENT_GUIDE.md
**Success Criteria:**
1. ✓ README documents docker-socket-proxy architecture (not direct socket mount)
2. ✓ README documents all v1.2 features (update all, batch selection improvements)
3. ✓ Setup instructions verified accurate for clean install
---
## Progress
| Phase | Name | Milestone | Status |
|-------|------|-----------|--------|
| 1-5 | Foundation through Polish | v1.0 | Complete |
| 6 | n8n API Access | v1.1 | Complete |
| 7 | Socket Security | v1.1 | Complete |
| 8 | Inline Keyboard Infrastructure | v1.1 | Complete |
| 9 | Batch Operations | v1.1 | Complete |
| 10 | Workflow Modularization | v1.2 | Complete |
| 10.1 | Aggressive Workflow Modularization | v1.2 | Complete |
| 10.2 | Better Logging & Log Management | v1.2 | Complete (descoped) |
| 11 | Update All & Callback Limits | v1.2 | Complete |
| 12 | Polish & Audit | v1.2 | Complete |
| 13 | Documentation Overhaul | v1.2 | Complete |
**v1.2 Coverage:** 12+ requirements mapped across 7 phases
---
*Updated: 2026-02-08 — Phase 13 complete (1/1 plans, v1.2 milestone COMPLETE)*